The Great Control Scheme Throwdown

Hello Fans and Friends,

The past week has been one of the most exciting in our ten year history. Having had the privilege of working with some truly fantastic developers and publishers, we launched our first original property with our awesome partners at Ubisoft. With the game in the wild for a few days, we’ve begun the processes of collating the massive pile of feedback from our forums, reviews and fans posting to social networks. Having shipped many games in the past, we’ve gotten pretty good at anticipating feedback we will get from players, but Shoot Many Robots has started an unexpected fervent debate.

The debate surrounds our decision to go with an old-school single stick control scheme (Hard Corps: Uprising, Metal Slug) rather than the more modern twin-stick (Comic Jumper, Crash Commando) approach. Shoot Many Robots doesn’t fit perfectly into the mold of other Run-n-Gun games. We have several abilities (jet packs, body slam, etc) that muck with the old paradigm. Additionally, the volume of enemies is greater, but the amount of bullet-dodging required is quite a bit lower. Your player is way heartier - able to take several hits without dying. This debate is made especially interesting given the long history of the Shoot Many Robots design. The designer at Demiurge who originally pitched this idea had this to say in his original one-page design: “Apply a new control scheme to a classic genre…It is a side scrolling shooter like Metal Slug or Mega Man X that utilizes the dual analog stick movement and shooting controls of games like Geometry Wars.” If you watch the Evolution of Shoot Many Robots dev diary, the parts of the video where the character is a stick figure are actually being controlled twin-stick style. We user-tested the crap out of our control schemes early in development and continued to refine the decisions throughout development.  The results of our user testing were crystal clear: When coupled with left-trigger aim-down-sights and jetpack abilities, single stick controls felt better to most players and enabled users to play more effectively (i.e., shoot more robots).

And now the players have spoken: Some praise us for the tight, simple controls, but a few have reamed us for having a pigheaded commitment to old-school gaming. While we frankly take that as a bit of a compliment, we made a mistake in focusing on the single stick control scheme. Both camps are right! Our testing showed us that the single-stick scheme was preferred by the majority - what it didn’t show was how strongly the minority would feel. If an FPS shipped today without the option to invert the Y-Axis most people wouldn’t care, but a sizable number of players would have a totally miserable experience. That is why ever since Halo 1 the Y-axis-inversion has been integrated into the tutorial for all top-tier FPS’s.

While we feel that both camps are “right”, we are all gamers here at Demiurge and that means we like to declare winners and losers. It is in that spirit that we’re announcing the great Control Scheme Throwdown at PAX East in a couple of weeks. On display at our booth, we’ll have a special build of the game rigged with both control schemes. We’ll have head-to-head competitions of SMR featuring each of the options and at the end of the show a victor will be declared. To show that we’re willing to put our money where our mouth is - if we end up patching Shoot Many Robots (which is not a certainty in the console world), we will include controller configuration in the patch and we’ll set the default to whatever wins at PAX!

We can’t wait to see everyone in our hometown of Boston in a few weeks. Our booth is #612 and as always will be staffed entirely by the game developers that work here at Demiurge. Whether you’re a traditionalist or not, please stop by, say “hi” and let us know how you feel!

Regards,
Al

The Great Control Scheme Throwdown

5550 comments (add a comment)

T Ross

Mar 24 2012

Hi,

I reviewed your game for our site, and like many other reviewers and many other games (for example, the people I played the game with on co-op), I could not get used to the controls in your game. Even if you are right, and single-stick was a better way of doing it, the control mechanism is still too tought to get used to.

Arguably, it would have been better to alter/simplify your game mechanics so that your controls worked better, than to have to choose between two awkard control schemes. It’s hard to know without trying it out, but, you could free up an entire button if you made revival time/proximity (stay near for 3 seconds) based rather than forcing players to have to press the button, something I found really hit and miss, especially while trying to fight off loads of robots.

I would be quite interested to hear (given that the likelihood of me turning up in PAX East is quite low - I live in Great Britain) how your twin-stick layout worked. I could definitely imagine plenty of ways it would work badly, but I’m still pretty convinced that it could work and would be the better system.

Either way, the fact that you are responding to feedback in this way is admirable, and I’m interested to hear the results of the showdown. Regardless of the result, I would urge you to patch the game to include twin-stick controls.

J

Mar 25 2012

It would be nice if you patched in 4 player local co-op.

Sylvia

Mar 28 2012

Amazing!!!

Paritselalu

Mar 31 2012

It’s a pleasure to find such rationality in an answer. Welcome to the dbetae.

Fix it

Apr 10 2012

It must have support to joystick, bad decision to remove it from pc version.

Best regards,

Alyssa Charles

Apr 11 2012

Thx for your post, I really enjoy your blog. Long time lurker, first time commenter, you know the drill. I tried to share this one time before, I don’t think it posted correctly…hopefully it will this time!   
My Bolg : DepressionSymptomsMedication.com

Jeroenske

Apr 12 2012

Twin-stick all the way baby ! Look at your pc version it is twin-stick already.You use the Mouse to aim and kb to move. Move and shoot. Need a button to free up ? Left trigger aiming is not needed with twin-stick scheme to begin with. I want to shoot with triggers instead of awkwardly pressing and holding X all the time.

paxil

Apr 13 2012

You are certainly right. In it something is and it is excellent thought. I support you.

neurontin

Apr 14 2012

I congratulate, the excellent answer.

Henrietta C. Patten

Apr 16 2012

Very awesome blog !! I couldnt have wrote this any better than you if I tried super hard hehe!! I like your style too!! it’s very unique & refreshing…

Quiteria Guardado Baeza

Apr 21 2012

you will have an amazing weblog here! would you prefer to make some invite posts on my weblog?

irommaadjoumb

May 16 2012

<a >sublingual viagra</a>  improves symptoms of right-sided heart failure. Because PDE-5 is primarily distributed within the <a >female viagra uk</a>  Do not take Viagra more than once a day. Allow 24 hours to pass between doses. Contact your doctor or seek e <a >viagra cost</a>  pills.[49] By 2007, Viagra’s global share had plunged to about 50 percent[50] due to several factors, <a >generic viagra no prescription</a>  is also informally known as “Vitamin V”, “the Blue Pill”, “Blue Diamond” as well as various other nicknames.[48] <a >viagra safe</a>,<a >viagra review</a>,<a >cialis tablets side effects</a>,<a >super cialis</a>

irommaadjoumb

May 17 2012

<a >online purchase viagra</a>  urge to share it with the world. <a >viagra jelly</a>  Interactions <a >buy viagra soft</a>  coronary artery disease; <a >alcohol and viagra</a>  I wasn’t aware these pills work with such effect! Getting me to feel excited is one thing, but the size of <a >viagra overnight delivery</a>,<a >viagra alternative</a>,<a >cialis tadalafil side effects</a>,<a >low dose cialis daily</a>

MegeaponeS

May 17 2012

<a >natural alternatives to viagra</a>  so get a prescription and purchase Viagra to revamp your sex life! <a >viagra oral</a>  protease inhibitors limit their use of sildenafil to no more than one 25 mg dose every 48 hours.[21] <a >best viagra</a>  result of their treatment. A 2003 study showed that sildenafil improved sexual function in men in this <a >viagra costs</a>  Stop using Viagra and get emergency medical help if you have sudden vision loss. <a >viagra pills</a>,<a >does female cialis work for women</a>,<a >branded cialis drugstore</a>,<a >cialis price canada</a>

MegeaponeS

May 17 2012

<a >buy brand name viagra cost</a>  Sudden decrease or loss of hearing has been rarely reported in people taking PDE5 inhibitors, including <a >viagra sale online</a>  I concluded Viagra pill is the one that provides the best results and, more importantly, it is completely <a >generic brands viagra online</a>  services of this site. <a >pfizer viagra brand sale</a>  some reason.[9] <a >how to use viagra</a>,<a >cialis alcohol</a>,<a >cialis 20mg generic</a>,<a >cheapest brand cialis</a>

Nilva

May 17 2012

A million tnhkas for posting this information.

Omar

May 17 2012

You coudln’t pay me to ignore these posts!

Ali

May 17 2012

With the bases loaded you srtuck us out with that answer!

Anil

May 17 2012

Son of a gun, this is so heulpfl!

Ahmet

May 17 2012

With all these silly websites, such a great page keeps my itnenert hope alive.

Marcie

May 17 2012

This “free sharing” of ifnomartion seems too good to be true. Like communism.

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.